Nonalcoholic drinks could prove beneficial for recovering alcoholics looking for sober drinking options. However, some say the cons of these beverages far outweigh the pros.
Nonalcoholic drinks contain little or no alcohol. Beer, wine and mixed drinks have nonalcoholic versions for people seeking the flavor of a cocktail without the accompanying buzz or hangover.
Often, individuals cannot tell the difference between alcoholic and nonalcoholic beverages. They are similar in taste, consistency and smell. The big difference: less alcohol.
For recovering alcoholics, these drinks have proved beneficial and important.
Nonalcoholic beverages are divided into two hallmark categories: low-alcohol and alcohol-free.
By definition, a low-alcoholic drink contains less than 0.5 percent alcohol by volume (ABV).
These drinks are ideal for moderate drinkers without health problems. The odds of becoming inebriated from a low-alcohol beverage are slim. In fact, minors can be served these drinks in the following states:
Alcohol-free drinks contain no alcohol. Everyone from designated drivers to pregnant women can consume these beverages, avoiding the risks involved with alcohol. They are the preferred option for those looking to avoid alcohol altogether, including recovering alcoholics.
Dr. Elizabeth Hartney, a licensed psychologist who specializes in addiction, says that alcohol-free beverages are a good option for individuals transitioning away from alcohol.
For moderate drinkers, nonalcoholic beverages could prove helpful. Instead of having a couple of beers each day after work, individuals can drink a low-alcohol version with similar qualities. This could help stave off long-term problems, including addiction.
On the surface, nonalcoholic beverages seem like a safe alternative to the real thing — especially for those in recovery. However, critics have argued to the contrary.
For recovering addicts, nonalcoholic drinks are a slippery slope. On one hand, it’s rare to reach intoxication by drinking low-alcohol beverages and impossible with alcohol-free drinks. On the other hand, it could reintroduce users to alcohol.
A study published by Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental noted how drinking alcohol releases a chemical in the brain called dopamine, which produces pleasure. The anticipation of alcohol could yield the same reaction.
Placebo effects, as these are called, can be experienced without actually consuming alcohol. Therefore, the smell and consistency of a nonalcoholic beverage could take a person back to a time before recovery — when alcohol dictated life choices. These drinks could spur cravings and give way to relapse.
Those who drink alcohol expect to feel its effects. This expectation can occur when a recovering alcoholic simply sips a nonalcoholic drink. Alcohol is not entering his system, but he may subconsciously seek a buzz.
This could trigger behavior in line with the consumption of high levels of alcohol. It could also lead to bloating, nausea, sweating and other health-related effects.
At least 90 percent of recovering alcoholics experience at least one relapse in the four years after cessation, per the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Alcohol addiction is a debilitating disease that affects millions of Americans each year. For those in recovery, a single drink could cause relapse.
These individuals often turn to a range of nonalcoholic beverages instead. Many forms exist, giving those in recovery a variety of options based on their preference.
For those who are not concerned about the effects of a low-alcohol drink, there are some options available.
Nonalcoholic beer is boiled to reduce its alcohol content. Billions of liters are consumed each year, making these brews the fastest-growing category of nonalcoholic beverages, per The Economist.
Low-alcohol wine, specifically red wine, contains several health benefits. Its antioxidants could help prevent heart disease and artery damage. Plus, these nonalcoholic options boast many of the same aromas found in regular wine.
Alcohol-free drinks present no risk of intoxication, but there are potential negative consequences. If you have determined that these drinks are not a threat to your sobriety, try some of these alcohol-free alternatives.
Nonalcoholic mixed beverages, or “virgin drinks,” are common nonalcoholic options. These could include juices, sparkling water and soda. For example, instead of a traditional bloody mary, individuals could mix tomato juice with a dash of Worcestershire and Tabasco sauce, topped off with a lemon.
Virgin cocktails, or “mocktails,” are healthy alternative for breakfast, lunch or dinner parties. A popular option is the Shirley Temple, which includes lemon-lime soda, ginger ale, a dash of grenadine and a cherry on top.
Of course, water is by far the best alternative to alcoholic beverages, and green tea has a host of health benefits.
Water is essential for those in recovery. In some settings, water mixed with diet soda or juice could give off the impression of alcohol and reduce social discomfort.
Coffee contains the most prevalent drug in the world: caffeine. However, a simple cup of joe is relatively harmless for recovering alcoholics.
Tea, particularly green tea, is a healthy option for those in recovery. Harvard University studies suggest coffee and tea reduce the chance for diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
In recent years, energy drinks have boomed in popularity. These beverages contain healthy ingredients, such as vitamins and herbs but also heavy amounts of caffeine. In fact, a typical energy drink may have as much caffeine as a cup of coffee.
The popularity of energy drinks has led to the creation of alcohol-filled energy drinks. These contain up to 12 percent alcohol by volume (ABV), nearly double that of a standard beer. They are consumed by 31 percent of teenagers and 34 percent of young adults, according to the National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence.
For recovering alcoholics, energy drinks can be problematic. A study by the University of Maryland and Johns Hopkins University confirmed that energy drink consumption can lead to alcohol abuse.
Before trying nonalcoholic beverages, speak with a medical expert who can further explain the pros and cons of these drinks and advise whether they would be counterproductive to you and your situation.